Skip to content

February 26, 2015

7

Time to stop doubting and learn to love immigration

by quaesitor
NBC 141106-uk-migrants mini

RANT ALERT (This is v abnormal for me, but I’m quite exercised about it!)

I’m getting tired of people complaining about immigration, and just wish politicians would have the courage to speak up for it. The UK has ALWAYS been a country of immigrants – you just have to look at the history of London’s East End over the last 5 centuries to see this. The fact is that it says a lot of positive things about the UK that people want to come here, not least in terms of the culture, the economy and the vibrancy. This should not be a Right/Left issue – it is a cheap and historically infamous shortcut to popularity and votes.

This is not to deny the problems re cultural ghettos and the benefits system scroungers etc – but these are separate issues IMHO. There are genuine political challenges in it – for all parties. But it is not immigrants’ fault that the system is faulty. [Nor do they cause congestion on motorways for that matter.] Here are some random thoughts, in random order, with no particular logic because I’m no political theorist by any stretch (as will be clear).

As I said, I’m just quite exercised and disturbed about it.

  • Montie - immigrationWhy is economic migration such a problem anyway? It has always happened and always will. And I know for a fact that many who abhor immigration would be tempted or driven to it in different circumstances. Just look at the myriad reasons for people emigrating from Europe to the USA a century ago. As I noticed one Tory commentator this morning, it should be a positive thing.
  • Immigrants often do the jobs ‘natives’ are too ambitious or proud to do. It has always happened and always will.
  • There are many more pressing issues in our society, like the wealth gap (or rather chasm) and the fallout that inevitably comes from that, the superficiality and foundationlessness (is that a word?!) of so much public ethics and theory, the relationship we all have with difference. Again, these should not really be right/left issues.
  • But quite apart from the politics of the issue, there is the ethics of it. The ‘other’ and the ‘different’ have always felt threatening to those who form the majority or the powerful. Very often that fear is derived from ignorance, prejudice and even insecurity. But a measure of any society’s health is how it looks after its vulnerable, weak and oppressed. This is nothing less than biblical morality (which, contrary to what many secular folks assume, is quite exceptional on this issue, and more than relevant in our generation, STILL):
  • Do not mistreat or oppress a foreigner, for you were foreigners in Egypt. Do not take advantage of the widow or the fatherless. If you do and they cry out to me, I will certainly hear their cry. My anger will be aroused… (Exodus 22:21-23)
  • When a foreigner resides among you in your land, do not mistreat them. The foreigner residing among you must be treated as your native-born. Love them as yourself, for you were foreigners in Egypt. I am the Lord your God. (Leviticus 19:33-34)
  • … et ad infinitum – there is a huge list of verses making this point.
  • George_Bernard_Shaw_1936There is a richness that comes from learning from those who are different. The years we lived in Uganda weren’t always the easiest – but I wouldn’t have missed it for the world. Uganda is a country that I now love deeply and I was changed by it profoundly. At the same time, it made me appreciate my own country all the more more, but paradoxically, at also relativised my patriotism. For there is actually something irrational about nationalism because it extends to its logical extreme George Bernard Shaw’s quip that patriotism is the conviction that “your country is superior to all other countries because you were born in it!”
  • I’m not sure there is such thing as a Christian country anyway… and if there is, it’s certainly not the kind that chucks out and excludes those who are different.

NBC 141106-uk-migrants-welcome-main_107ba57ca171dab827654ec3163c8077This is not to deny that there must be obligations and expectations on those who live within a community different from their own – and there are all kinds of reasons behind why they don’t. It is a big job to help people adjust and acclimatise. But there are also major issues of how locals accept outsiders – and this is where those of us in any demographic majority, as well as those who hold political power or influence, have a duty (it is nothing less) to protect, support and encourage the ‘alien in the land.’

So I’m innately suspicious of rabble-rousing soapbox politics that refuses to acknowledge the benefits of, and responsibilities to, immigrants. That’s where things must start. It’s only in that kind of positive atmosphere can we begin to tackle issues of assimilation and cultural engagement, as well as all the challenges associated with a plural society. The current rhetoric and scapegoating merely alienate and endanger the vulnerable, and they corrode our moral well-being. They certainly make it infinitely harder to tackle the rights of the vulnerable in the world’s regimes that are clearly more oppressive than ours.

Rant over for now… I’m not really going to engage in heated online debates about this, though. I find such things are usually fruitless and just invitations for trollers. But this is my blog – and I can say what I want to on it!

7 Comments Post a comment
  1. Feb 26 2015

    Reblogged this on Svědek and commented:
    A great piece on immigration from Mark Meynell. Expresses much of what I think about this – only he puts it better!

    Reply
  2. SeekTruthFromFacts
    Feb 26 2015

    “Finally, I wish to speak directly to those who came to London today to take life.
    I know that you personally do not fear giving up your own life in order to take others – that is why you are so dangerous. But I know you fear that you may fail in your long-term objective to destroy our free society and I can show you why you will fail.

    In the days that follow, look at our airports, look at our sea ports and look at our railway stations and, even after your cowardly attack, you will see that people from the rest of Britain, people from around the world will arrive in London to become Londoners and to fulfil their dreams and achieve their potential.

    They choose to come to London, as so many have come before because they come to be free, they come to live the life they choose, they come to be able to be themselves. They flee you because you tell them how they should live. They don’t want that and nothing you do, however many of us you kill, will stop that flight to our city where freedom is strong and where people can live in harmony with one another. Whatever you do, however many you kill, you will fail.”
    Ken Livingston, 7 July 2005

    Whatever else immigrants may be, they are certainly a reason for British citizens to thank God that they have received through no merit of their own what other people struggle long and hard to reach.

    Reply
  3. Júlio Reis
    Feb 27 2015

    Yes, stop treating immigrants like criminals, while at the same time extorting their money. A colleague of mine who by unchance had to move into the UK from a former British colony in Africa was absolutely skinned for his money, and made to go through the most humiliating hoops, just to be able to live in the UK. He wasn’t positively discriminated for the fact that he holds a PhD in science. I think he’s a humbler person than I am, because I would be so furious if I had to go through all that. As things stand, I would just have to pack my things and arrive—nothing more. But the way Government treats foreigners makes me not want to go live there. Everything else is good though, that’s a nice country / set of countries you have there.

    Reply
  4. Júlio Reis
    Feb 27 2015

    Oh, and a nice coincidence: today’s “40 Acts” is about cultural diversity: http://www.40acts.org.uk/the-challenge/mix-it-up

    Reply
  5. Tom
    Feb 27 2015

    I agree with you almost whole-heartedly Mark. My only apprehension towards what you euphemistically call “political challenges”.
    I like immigration; it brings knowledge of different cultures, wonderful cuisine, people who’s native situation leads them to demonstrate an attitude of determination and initiative when given the freedoms and opportunities we take for granted in this country.

    But: I can afford to live somewhere where my neighbours are not predominantly families in which the women must veil their faces and are not culturally allowed to interact with me. I can afford to enjoy the benefits of immigration, I am unaffected by the less positive impact on community cohesion.
    I have no time for essentially racist “no to Johnny Foreigner”, “protect English culture” arguments. But when people feel unwelcome, alienated, even intimidated in the areas in which they grew up due to massive influx of a particular group who then make it progressively easier for others of the same culture to live here without acclimatising at all – then I find it difficult to tell people “stop doubting and enjoy immigration!”

    Reply
    • Feb 27 2015

      Hi Tom
      I do agree with you – and I think issues of how integration and accommodation happen are essential and urgent – as I say, there are obligations and responsibilities that come on all.

      I suppose all I was trying to say was that these are surely secondary to the rightness of immigration.

      Reply

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Gleanings from this week’s news | Katartizo

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Note: HTML is allowed. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to comments

%d bloggers like this: